Pastors at Nanjemoy Baptist Church
1793 – 1809 Andrew Leach
1814 - 1820 Samuel L. Straughan
1821 - 1833 Unknown
1834 – 1836 Thomas Conduit
1837 – 1855 William I Chiles
1857 – 1857 Charles Griffen
1859 – 1863 Isaac F Stidham
1864 – 1865 John Bray
1866 – 1874 William I Chiles
1875 – 1878 Samuel Saunders 
1879 – 1879 A.W. Graves
1881 – 1882 A.J. Ashburn
1883 – 1884 G.V. Board
1886 – 1886 E.C. Allard
1886 – 1890 T.A. Reid
1891 - ? T.W. Newman
1893 – 1900 John R. Thomas 
1901 – 1903 Lewis Jones
1904 – 1912 J.M. Thomas 
1912 – 1915 J.J. Cain
1915 – 1916 L.B. Kirby 
1917 – 1918 Hugh P. Vinson
1920 – 1920 Lewis Jones
1921 - 1923 O.D. Ramey 
1923 – 1928 T.L. Scruggs 
1928 – 1929 G.L. Hostetter 
1930 – 1930 W.R. Vaiden
1930 – 1936 Frank E. Clarke 
1936 – 1938 L.P. Barnette 
1939 – 1947 C.C. Nanney 
1947 – 1950 W.E. Abrams 
1950 – 1956 G.D. Renegar 
1957 – 1963 Buford C. Sellers 
1963 – 1966 C.D. Canady 
1967 – 1971 Marvin Whisnant 
1971 – 1972 Conrad Burch 
1973 – 1976 C.S. Hendon 
1977 – 1988 James C. Cunningham 
1989 – 1990 Theodore Eugene Thieman, Sr. 
1990 - 1999 James C. Cunningham
2000 - 2007 James E. Fetty 
2007- 2012 Brian M. Corrick 
2013 - 2014 Scott E. Campbell 
2014 - 2025 Michael C. Spencer 
